Penny + Grace Review January 2020

Penny + Grace is a monthly jewelry subscription. For $24.99 they’ll send you a trio (3) of their hottest, trendiest jewelry picks. Share your new accessories with friends, or keep them all to yourself! All items are yours to keep, and every order has a guaranteed retail value of $55.00+… They kindly sent us this box for review.

When it comes to jewelry I prefer simple pieces that can be worn often as opposed to elaborate pieces that can only be worn with certain outfits. I think this is why I love my Penny + Grace subscription so much. The pieces are simple yet beautiful and sometimes fun. I say “fun” because each collection has a theme and in the past we have received some really fun collections based on themes such as travel, beach vacays, and fall…..just to name a few.

Subscription Details

Penny + Grace subscriptions are available in 18k Yellow Gold, Silver, + 18k Rose Gold options. Your color preference can be changed at any time throughout the life of your subscription within your account portal.

Each monthly order comes neatly packed in a convenient signature faux leather clutch.

Fear of commitment? No problem, you can skip or cancel your deliveries at any time.

All jewelry is 100% Lead and Nickel Free – Perfect for those with sensitive skin.

Here’s a closer look at the pieces I received in my January Penny + Grace package…..

Navy Pouch

Your Penny + Grace jewelry ships in an outer bubble mailer each month and tucked inside is this gorgeous little pouch. For November we received a black pouch, for December we received a pale pink pouch and this month we received a navy pouch. I was trying to figure out if we would receive different colors each month and it appears as though we will. I’m hoping for a red pouch next month.


Here we have a beautiful silver necklace with a double heart pendant. I happen to love hearts. Some of my all-time favorite jewelry pieces have hearts on them so I already know this will be a go-to necklace. And……it arrived prior to Valentine’s Day which makes me very happy.


Next we have a bracelet to match the necklace. I would have loved to receive a pair of heart earrings in it’s place, but I really shouldn’t complain because this bracelet is so darn cute.


As per usual I am in LOVE with the ring. It ends up being my favorite piece each and every time they include one in the collection. We don’t always receive rings, sometimes we receive earrings. This month we received a gorgeous little ring with hearts all around. I love the size and style. It’s not too big, it’s simple, and the hearts add just a touch of flare. I will wear this often.

Penny + Grace Review January 2020 – Final Thoughts

The January Penny + Grace collection is absolute perfection. They went with a heart theme which is perfect for the upcoming holiday. I LOVE that we received a Valentines themed collection in January as I will be able to wear these pieces for all of February – the month of love. This was great planning on their part. The ring is my favorite item this month, as it usually is. And I love that we have been receiving different color pouches. I can’t wait to see what color we receive next. When it comes to price point and curation Penny + Grace is a no-brainer.

-AYOB Sarah

Penny + Grace

Join the club! For $24.99, we'll deliver a trio (3) of our very best monthly jewelry picks.

Learn More about Penny + Grace »

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *